Why Narendra Modi is struggling to keep his grip on India

Why Narendra Modi is struggling to keep his grip on India

The myth of Narendra Modi’s invincibility didn't just crack; it shattered. For a decade, the Indian Prime Minister operated with the kind of absolute authority that made the Prime Minister's Office look more like a monarch's court. But look at the state of New Delhi today in April 2026. The swagger is gone. The "double engine" growth rhetoric is sputtering. Modi isn't just fighting the opposition anymore; he's fighting his own allies, a rebellious judiciary, and a map of India that refuses to turn entirely saffron.

You've probably heard the narrative that Modi is "locking down" power because he's stronger than ever. That’s wrong. It’s actually the opposite. Every aggressive move he makes right now—the sudden "cleaning" of voter rolls, the desperate push for constitutional amendments—is a symptom of a leader who knows the ground is shifting beneath his feet.

The coalition trap and the end of the bulldozer era

Modi’s biggest headache isn't Rahul Gandhi. It's the math. Since the 2024 elections, the BJP hasn't had the luxury of a single-party majority. For years, they "bulldozed" legislation through Parliament without a second thought. Now? They're stuck in the mud of coalition politics.

Take the recent failure of the Constitution (One Hundred and Thirty-First Amendment) Bill. This wasn't just a minor legislative hiccup. It was the first time in 12 years that a flagship Modi amendment got shot down. The plan was to link women's seat reservations to a "delimitation" exercise—basically redrawing the electoral map to favor the BJP's northern strongholds. The opposition smelled the trap and, for once, stayed united.

When you can’t pass laws, you lose the "strongman" aura. And in Indian politics, aura is everything.

Why the South is saying no

If you look at a political map of India, there’s a massive divide. The North is largely BJP territory, but the South is a different planet. States like Tamil Nadu and Kerala view New Delhi's moves with deep suspicion.

  • Financial unfairness: Southern states contribute more to the federal treasury but feel they get less back.
  • Political erasure: The delimitation plan would effectively punish the South for having better population control, reducing their seat count while rewarding the North.
  • Cultural friction: The push for Hindi and "One Nation" policies feels like an invasion to many in Chennai or Bengaluru.

The desperate scramble to fix the voter lists

Since Modi can't easily change the laws anymore, the strategy has shifted to changing the voters. In the 2026 West Bengal elections, we're seeing something called "Special Intensive Revision" (SIR) of voter lists. It sounds like boring paperwork. It’s actually a political weapon.

In Bengal, the electorate dropped by about 12% almost overnight. In some districts, more than a million names vanished. The BJP calls it "cleaning" the rolls of illegal immigrants. The opposition calls it "voter suppression." When you look at the data, the names being deleted are disproportionately from communities that don't vote for the BJP.

It’s a classic move: if you can't win the game, change who's allowed to play. Honestly, it’s a sign of weakness, not strength. A confident leader doesn't need to delete 10% of the voters to win an election.

Using the state as a shield

When the ballot box becomes unpredictable, the "agencies" become the primary tool of governance. We've seen a massive spike in the use of the Enforcement Directorate (ED) and the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) against political rivals.

Think about it. If you’re a regional leader and you see your peers getting arrested or having their bank accounts frozen, you're much more likely to "cooperate" with the central government. This isn't just about fighting corruption; it's about political survival.

  1. Arresting the critics: High-profile arrests of Chief Ministers are now common.
  2. Institutional capture: Putting loyalists in charge of the Election Commission and university boards.
  3. NGO crackdown: Effectively banning foreign funding for organizations that track human rights or environmental issues.

The economy isn't the savior it used to be

The government loves to talk about India being the "fastest-growing economy." On paper, the numbers look great. GDP is up. Defence exports hit a record ₹38,424 crore this past year. But talk to a regular person in a small town, and the story is different.

The unemployment rate is "declining" according to official stats, but the quality of jobs is terrible. Most people are stuck in low-paying gig work or informal labor. The manufacturing boom that Modi promised—the "Make in India" dream—hasn't really materialised for the masses. Foreign companies are wary of the erratic regulatory environment.

If people aren't feeling the "Amrit Kaal" (Golden Age) in their pockets, they stop caring about the grand nationalist rhetoric.

Is there a way out for the BJP

Don't count Modi out yet. He still has a massive, well-oiled organizational machine and a personal popularity rating that most Western leaders would kill for. He's also leaning hard into "Operation Sindoor" and other high-stakes security plays to remind everyone that he’s the only one who can keep India safe.

But the 2026 state elections are proving that the old tricks aren't working like they used to. The Trinamool Congress in Bengal is holding its ground despite the voter list "cleansing." New players, like the actor-turned-politician Vijay in Tamil Nadu, are disrupting the old alliances.

Modi's attempt to "lock down" power is a race against time. He’s trying to consolidate everything before the coalition cracks completely.

If you want to understand where India is heading, stop looking at the Prime Minister’s speeches. Look at the state-level election results and the court rulings that are starting to push back. The era of the "unquestioned leader" is over. What comes next is a messy, loud, and very Indian struggle for the soul of the country.

Pay attention to the upcoming Supreme Court hearings on federalism and state rights—that’s where the real power struggle is happening. If the courts hold the line, the "lockdown" will fail.

Analysis of India's 2024 Election Results

This video provides a detailed breakdown of the 2024 election shift that stripped the BJP of its absolute majority, explaining the fundamental math that now constrains Modi's power.

RM

Riley Martin

An enthusiastic storyteller, Riley captures the human element behind every headline, giving voice to perspectives often overlooked by mainstream media.