The Erasure of the Spine Sheema Kirmani and the War on Public Joy

In the sweltering humidity of a Karachi afternoon on May 5, 2026, a 75-year-old woman with silver hair and an unyielding posture was pulled from her small car and bundled into a police van. To the global audience that streamed Coke Studio’s "Pasoori" over half a billion times, she is the ethereal figure in the gold-bordered sari, her hands tracing ancient geometry in the background of a pop sensation. To the Sindh Police, Sheema Kirmani was simply a veteran agitator to be silenced before she could reach a microphone at the Karachi Press Club.

The detention of Kirmani and several other Aurat March organizers—including transgender activist Shahzadi Rai—was technically over a "No Objection Certificate" (NOC) for a press conference. But the optics of veiled policewomen physically manhandling a classical dance icon reveal a much deeper, more jagged fissure in the Pakistani state’s relationship with its own culture. This wasn't just a bureaucratic dispute. It was a physical confrontation between a woman who has spent fifty years "straightening the spine" of the marginalized and a state apparatus that remains allergic to women claiming public space. Don't miss our earlier post on this related article.

The Body as a Battlefield

For Kirmani, the act of Bharatanatyam in Pakistan has never been a mere hobby. It is a political manifesto. She began her training in the mid-1960s, but it was during the 1980s under General Zia-ul-Haq’s martial law that her art became an act of treason. When the state banned dance, labeling it "un-Islamic" and "anti-national," Kirmani didn't retreat to private salons. She took to the stage.

Her philosophy is grounded in the literal anatomy of resistance. She often speaks of the "straightening of the spine" in her teachings. In her view, a woman standing tall, moving with deliberate grace and strength, is a direct threat to a social order that requires her to cower. When the police pulled her from her vehicle last Tuesday, they weren't just arresting a person; they were attempting to bend a spine that has refused to curve for seven decades. If you want more about the background of this, The Guardian provides an in-depth breakdown.

The Pasoori Paradox

The "Pasoori" music video served as a global reintroduction for Kirmani, yet it created a strange paradox. While the state celebrates the soft power of "Coke Studio" and the international accolades it brings to the "Brand Pakistan" image, it simultaneously suppresses the very individuals who provide that cultural depth.

Ali Sethi, the song’s creator, described "Pasoori" as a "flower bomb hurled at nationalism and heteropatriarchy." Kirmani’s presence in the video wasn't accidental; she was the physical embodiment of that dissent. However, the viral fame of the song hasn't protected her from the grit of Karachi’s streets. The same government that might tweet about the song's success is the one authorizing the "rough handling" of its star when she asks for the right to march for labor rights and gender safety.

The Shrinking Civic Square

The 2026 Aurat March is facing a familiar gauntlet of "conditional" approvals. The Sindh government recently issued an NOC, but with strings attached—restrictions on slogans, clothing, and the very timing of the event. This tactical bureaucracy is a refined version of the blunt-force bans of the past. By delaying permits until the eleventh hour and then arresting organizers for attempting to discuss those delays, the state creates a perpetual state of legal limbo.

The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) has correctly identified this as a "systematic denial of public space." It is a strategy of exhaustion. If the state can make the mere act of holding a press conference so physically and legally taxing, they hope the movement will eventually lose its momentum.

• Targeted Detentions: Selecting high-profile figures like Kirmani to send a message to younger volunteers.
• Bureaucratic Obstruction: Using the "NOC" as a weaponized gatekeeping tool.
• Selective Morality: Enforcing Section 144 against activists while allowing larger, often more volatile, religious or political gatherings to proceed unchecked.

A History of Defiance

This isn't Kirmani's first brush with the authorities, and it likely won't be her last. In 2017, after a suicide bombing at the shrine of Lal Shahbaz Qalandar in Sehwan, she traveled to the site of the carnage. Amid the blood and the rubble, she performed the dhamaal—a Sufi dance. It was a fierce, wordless reclamation of a space that extremists had tried to claim through violence.

She has performed in factory yards for unionizing women and in rural villages to talk about the trauma of child marriage. Her organization, Tehrik-e-Niswan, uses theater and dance not for entertainment, but as a "solution-oriented" tool. They teach women how to catch a hand raised in violence—literally and metaphorically.

The Policy of "Zero Tolerance" vs. Reality

In the wake of the international and local outcry following the May 5 arrests, Sindh Home Minister Ziaul Hassan Lanjar was quick to issue a "zero-tolerance" statement regarding the misuse of authority. Three police officials, including a Deputy Superintendent and a Women Station House Officer, were suspended. The Minister even personally phoned Kirmani to express regret.

However, veteran analysts in the region view these suspensions as a standard "pressure valve" tactic. Suspending a few low-level officers does little to change the systemic directive that views feminist activism as a security threat. The "regret" of a minister is cold comfort when the underlying policy remains the suppression of dissent under the guise of maintaining public order.

The demand for 2026 remains unchanged: an unconditional right to assembly. The Aurat March organizers have made it clear that they are not seeking a "favor" from the government, but the exercise of a constitutional right.

Why This Matters Beyond Pakistan

The struggle of Sheema Kirmani is a localized version of a global trend: the sanitization of culture. We see it when protest music is stripped of its context to become a TikTok trend, or when cultural icons are invited to state dinners but arrested at state borders.

When a society attempts to separate the "art" (the beautiful dancer in the video) from the "artist" (the woman being dragged into a police mobile), it loses the soul of its culture. Kirmani’s dance is inseparable from her politics. You cannot have the beauty of her Bharatanatyam without the iron in her spine that keeps her standing at the gates of the Karachi Press Club.

The police might have released her "without reason" a few hours after her arrest, but the reason for the arrest was never in doubt. It was an attempt to remind the woman who taught a nation to stand straight that the state still holds the power to make her sit in a cage. They simply forgot that Sheema Kirmani has been practicing her posture for fifty years.

Sheema Kirmani speaking at Aurat March

This video provides direct footage of the aftermath of the arrests and the specific context of the police actions at the Karachi Press Club.
http://googleusercontent.com/youtube_content/1